Sunday, September 30, 2012

Guantanamo

(Note: I had to write this blog entry for a class I'm currently taking called the Guantanamo Public Memory Project. More info here: http://hrcolumbia.org/guantanamo/)

Guantánamo.

What does this word call to mind?  Until starting the Guantánamo Public Memory Project, my mind conjured up several thoughts upon hearing this word — injustice, torture, the War on Terror — and then went blank, only to be replaced by feelings of confusion and ignorance.  I like to think that I’m a well-informed individual, but in the case of Guantánamo, I quickly realized how little I knew.
This troubled me.  After having now read more deeply into Guantánamo’s past and present, I wondered what my previous lack of knowledge and lack of interest could stem from.
From the start of this project, I noticed how little we hear about Guantánamo today.  I would say that I experienced the height of media coverage and the torture debate surrounding the detention camp while I was in high school, which, as a graduate student, feels far off.  Between then and now, so many other events have demanded our nation’s limited attention.  There have been natural disasters, uprisings, changes in government, and the economic crisis.  Guantánamo seems not to have changed and therefore faded out of memory.
I think some of my confusion about Guantánamo can be linked to its fading from our national consciousness.  What is going on there right now?  Why can’t it be shut down?
The answers, if there are any definite ones, are frustratingly complex.  This layer of complexity now arises when I think about Guantánamo.  While researching the legal rights of the current detainees, I encountered the government’s attempts to mold policies, court rulings that grew increasingly strict, laws that seemed designed to spite these rulings, and the government’s indecision due to lack of legal precedent.  Despite my lack of fluency in legal jargon, I waded through various primary sources, from court cases to the Geneva Conventions.  I would guess that were other average Americans to brave this reading, they too would share my initial confusion over references to previous court cases and the language that allowed the government to create “enemy combatants.”  Guantánamo cannot be easily figured out, even amongst policy-makers and legal experts, and this complexity is a lesson in itself.  This complexity is bound up with the present-day status of Guantánamo and I believe that it shows that in order to understand Guantánamo, we have to accept a certain level of not understanding.
Even though we might not understand everything that has happened at Guantánamo, we can accept that many injustices took place and are taking place there.  But how have so many of us in the United States become immune to this injustice; how has it lost relevancy?  Again, I would suppose that a factor might be the lack of serious attention given to Guantánamo in the media. The article “Comfort, irony, and trivialization: The mediation of torture,” by Marita Sturken, proposes that the way that torture is treated in the media, and by our society more generally, can explain this inattention.  She writes that images, like the one of the prisoner in Iraqi prison Abu Ghraib, may have lost their power by becoming icons and part of the everyday.  Torture has been trivialized by downplaying its awfulness (“hey, work is torture too”) and even creating jokes around it, like on kitschy T-shirts (“Greetings from GITMO Resort and Spa”).  We use these methods to distance ourselves from the painful reality, thereby creating our own reality in which we don’t have to deal with the pain.  Many Americans have grown to accept the quandary that is Guantánamo.  Even if we do feel outraged about torture, amidst the complex veil of Guantánamo, we aren’t sure what we can do about it or why it matters.  We may not like its continued existence, but we see no way out and have come to accept it.
Hopefully the more we discuss these issues surrounding Guantánamo, the more relevant and understandable they will become and we can come closer to resolving this era of the base’s history.

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Living Without a Car

I have now gone pretty much a year without a car, but it hasn't been so much of a conscious thought until the past month.
Being in Indianapolis my public transportation options have shrunk immensely, particularly in how often, how late, and how punctually buses run.  At the same time, I've been relying on my bike more, and since I happen to live in a very convenient location to both campus and my internship site, biking and even walking are not so bad and in some cases, I think just as quick as driving.  It's just those places where biking gets a little far when I run into issues.
Has being carless put a crimp in my style?  Yes, in some ways, admittedly.  There are some places I would like to visit or things I would've like to have done but haven't yet because I haven't wanted to figure out transportation or there simply hasn't been any connection.  (Note: This applies to Indianapolis, not Germany, where public transportation never hindered me).  Some of it is of course just the initial apprehension of going further out to a place I've never been and being able to get back.  Not that that's completely new - I also had stress last year figuring out various routes to and from school that also did not run as often as in the city.  In some senses, the main issue is learning to trust the buses here.  In Germany, I could be pretty sure that they would always be punctual and would connect you to the right places.  Here, I'm not so sure.
The one thing is that when you go carless, you adjust.  You build your lifestyle to take that into account and make it work.  I have to say that I'm very grateful for some nice bike rides around the city and for early mornings waiting for the bus in the fresh air.  It is nice to have that commute time to also be outside and to get exercise.  Really, it's a great way to stay fit and also be able to let your mind wander a bit more than if you were driving.  I do have to put more thought into planning my week dependent on weather and just how tired my legs are, but overall I can get to the places I need to go to (the places I want to go to are a bit of a different case).  It's a slightly different lifestyle than the one I'd have with a car, but so far, I have no major complaints.
One thing I will add is that I've become very aware of is how being carless almost makes a political statement.  Though I don't have too much experience on different bus routes yet, I would say that most of my fellow bus riders are from a very different demographic than me and I think there are far fewer student-types riding the bus here than in Pittsburgh even.  It makes me realize that in order for any change to come about with public transportation, I have to actually use it and show that people like me (educated and white) will use the bus.  I have survived with public transportation, and if I can do it, I think other people can do.  Like most things in life, you just need to adjust.

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Musings of the Moment

Now that I'm no longer abroad, my blog title has changed, and it might change again.  Right now, I'm considering what direction I want to take with it, but I think it will cover some similar topics, just from Indianapolis, not Hannover.